What Desperate Things Did Civil War Soldiers Do to Survive the Cold?

by Hardtack & Coffee
published on 05 November 2026

bookmark_addbookmark_addedSave Video

Twelve degrees, sleet off the river, no coat, no blanket and no fire allowed... so a private at Fort Donelson stands up in the dark and starts walking in a tiny circle. All night. What did Civil War soldiers really do when the cold turned deadly?

In this documentary we follow an imagined but typical Illinois private through the most desperate winter nights of the war: fence rails burned "one top rail at a time" and a single Stafford County farm that lost 170 cords of oak and 2,700 rails to the Union army, the Crimean oven that put the fire under the tent floor, Confederates at Fort Donelson wrapped in quilts and cut-up carpet, sleeping beside a bonfire and rolling over all night, the myth that snow is a warm blanket, Stonewall Jackson's icy Romney Expedition and the protest that made him resign, rags, old hats and rawhide moccasins on bare feet, the old advice to rub frozen feet with snow, the looting of Fredericksburg and the night on the slope below Marye's Heights, Joshua Chamberlain behind the fallen, the ice storm that froze the Battle of Nashville for a week, and the prison camps at Elmira and Belle Isle. Then we look at who the cold hit hardest, and at the one ordinary thing that may have mattered most.

What do we know, and what is debated? The "top rail" order is a camp story and may never have been given word for word. Henry Kyd Douglas's tale of the soldier whose blanket caught fire comes from a memoirist known for embellishing. Numbers of barefoot men (such as "one in five" at Nashville) are estimates. Reports of furniture and pianos burned at Fredericksburg come from several accounts but vary. John Ransom published his Belle Isle and Andersonville diary years later and revised it. Temperatures at Elmira vary by source; the National Park Service gives 10 to 15 degrees below zero. Modern frostbite care is different from 19th-century advice: never rub frozen skin with snow.

Built from soldiers' own memoirs, letters and diaries (John Ransom, John O. Casler, Henry Kyd Douglas, Eugene Blackford, Joshua L. Chamberlain), official reports, and National Park Service histories.

CHAPTERS
0:00 Twelve Degrees at Fort Donelson
1:00 Farm Boys, Not Polar Explorers
2:07 Wind, Wet and Stillness
2:41 A Man Froze Where I Slept
3:26 Burn Anything
3:52 Only the Top Rail
4:35 One Farm, 2,700 Rails
5:29 Fire Under the Floor
7:07 Quilts, Carpets and Parkas
8:11 Turning Like Meat on a Spit
8:50 The Blanket That Caught Fire
9:53 Is Snow Warm?
11:21 The Icy Road to Romney
12:32 Stonewall Jackson Quits
13:40 Rags, Hats and Rawhide
14:48 Too Cold to Chase
15:27 Rub It With Snow
17:13 Pianos in the Fire
18:09 The Night on the Slope
19:24 The Professor Behind the Fallen
20:24 Nashville Frozen in Ice
21:41 The General Nearly Fired
22:54 Hellmira
24:26 Who the Cold Hit Hardest
25:57 The Whole System
26:43 Closing the Loops
28:39 Back to Fort Donelson

SOURCES AND FURTHER READING
John L. Ransom, Andersonville Diary (1881), Belle Isle entries, November 1863 to February 1864
National Park Service, Civil War Series: "The Campaign for Fort Donelson"
Discover Stafford (Stafford County Historical Society): the Union occupation of 1862–63 and the Concord receipt
Emerging Civil War, "The Romney Expedition" series (John O. Casler, Alfred Edgar, Henry Kyd Douglas)
Official Records and Jackson's letter to Secretary of War Judah P. Benjamin, January 31, 1862
William M. Blackford diary, January 1862 (University of Virginia, "150 Years Ago")
National Park Service, Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania: the battle, the looting of Fredericksburg and the burial of the dead (report of Col. John R. Brooke, 53rd Pennsylvania)
Joshua L. Chamberlain, "My Story of Fredericksburg" (Cosmopolitan, 1912)
Medical and Surgical History of the War of the Rebellion; Dominique Larrey and the history of frostbite treatment
Battle of Nashville Trust and Metro Nashville historical markers: the ice storm of December 1864
National Park Service, Civil War Series: "Civil War Prison Camps" (Elmira)
Encyclopedia Virginia, "Belle Isle Prison"

Illustrations are artistic reconstructions.

#CivilWar #CivilWarHistory #AmericanHistory