The Cold War had multiple origins, beginning with events during the Second World War (1939 to 45) and, as that conflict came to an end, the demise of the Grand Alliance of the USA, the USSR, and Great Britain. The Alliance quickly began to show serious cracks in unity over issues such as a permanent US military presence in Europe, economic aid to devastated states, Soviet occupation of Central and Eastern Europe, and the status of Germany in a postwar world. Mutual suspicion and ideological differences led to the establishment of two rival blocs of states, the US-led NATO and the USSR-led Warsaw Pact. There then followed four decades of the Cold War, when the East faced off against the West both in proxy wars and in an arms and space race.
The origins of the Cold War are many and varied. Some of the causes suggested by historians include:
- The fall of the pre-WWII European empires left a power vacuum, which the world's two superpowers, the USSR and USA, jostled to fill.
- Historical animosity dating back to the Russian Revolution and Russian Civil War.
- Two opposing ideologies: capitalism v. communism.
- Two opposing forms of government: democracy v. dictatorship.
- Two opposing military alliances: NATO v. Warsaw Pact.
- The USSR's sense of geographical insecurity.
- The permanent US military presence in Europe.
- Disagreement over the future of states like Germany, Poland, and Greece.
- A desire by both sides to make other states their allies.
- The nuclear arms race.
- Internal lobby groups pushing for confrontation.
- The independent and self-interested actions of allies of the two superpowers.
- The overestimation of the opposition's strength, underestimation of their security concerns, and misreading of real intentions by both sides.
The Allies of WWII had found themselves thrown together by circumstances. They were separated by ideological differences but unified in a desire to defeat Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, and militarist Japan. The Grand Alliance of the USA, Great Britain, and the USSR was formed in June 1941, when Nazi Germany invaded the USSR in Operation Barbarossa. Cracks had already begun to appear in this uneasy relationship long before the war ended.
There was the uneasy reality that the Western states knew of Stalin's atrocities committed to keep himself dictator of the USSR. Stalin, on the other side, was convinced that the Western powers intended to one day attack the Soviet Union. Western powers had, after all, supported opposition to the Bolsheviks/Communists during the Russian Civil War (1917 to 22) and excluded the USSR from international diplomacy throughout the 1920s.
Stalin, although aware through the work of his spies that the Allies had a nuclear weapon, may well have considered his suspicions of US-UK motives confirmed by the fact that the USSR was not officially informed earlier of the lengthy Manhattan Project nuclear programme.
Despite the mutual suspicion, the Allies' relationship was helped by the fact that the USSR's Red Army largely fought in separate theatres of the war from the US, British, and other Allied forces, compartmentalising the relationship into one of military necessity. The US, as it did with Britain, also supplied the USSR with financial and material aid through the Lend-Lease programme.
The leaders of the USA, Great Britain, and the USSR met several times in conferences during the war to thrash out ideas for what the postwar world would look like. At the Yalta Conference in Crimea in February 1945, the UK prime minister, Winston Churchill, the president of the United States, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and the leader of the USSR, Joseph Stalin, all met to discuss how WWII would end and such details as how Germany and Austria would henceforth be ruled. A new set of borders was tentatively agreed upon for Poland, essentially shifting the country westward at the expense of Germany. Churchill managed to extract a promise from Stalin that Poland would have free elections, and if voted in, members of the Polish government in exile would be permitted to retake office. There was disagreement over the fate of Greece and Bulgaria, with Roosevelt and Churchill wanting free elections and Stalin the placement of Communists within these governments, no matter what. There was also disagreement over control of the oil fields in Persia (modern Iran).
The Declaration on Liberated Europe was issued at Yalta, which "committed the UK, USA, and USSR to establishing free elections and democratic governments in the countries they had liberated" (Dear, 222). This declaration was not to prove of any value, as it was broken just a few weeks later when Stalin installed a new Soviet-backed government in Romania.
The last of the big conferences was held at Potsdam, eastern Germany, in July and August 1945. Roosevelt had died, Churchill was voted out of office mid-conference, and so only Stalin remained of the original 'Big Three' war leaders. Germany had already surrendered in April 1945, and the USSR's Red Army had occupied Berlin. It was decided at Potsdam that a Council of Foreign Ministers would be formed to define the new borders within Europe and decide how to carve up the various colonies of the war's losing powers. This was, in effect, a postponement of several issues where no agreement could be reached, and there were many.
The leaders at least agreed to deliver a surrender ultimatum to Japan. Stalin promised to actively help in the defeat of Japan if such a call was ignored, which it was. Soviet intervention turned out to be unnecessary when two atomic bombs were dropped by US aircraft on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, thereby bringing Japan's surrender in August and so with it the end of WWII.
Stalin was now determined to use his territorial gains in the war to create a buffer zone of satellite states that would prevent another invasion of the USSR. The new leaders of the West, Clement Attlee in the UK and Harry S. Truman in the US, were equally determined that as many European states as possible which had been democratically free before the war would return to that state of affairs, certainly that they would not become Communist-controlled. This latter ambition was then extended to any country in the world, including Japan. Disputed regions included the Balkans, Turkey, Greece, and the Middle East.
The freedom and independence of Poland had been one of the main reasons WWII had started, and the same state was a source of dispute between the US and Britain on the one side and the USSR on the other. Crucially for the subsequent political wrangling, Stalin's Red Army had already occupied much of Central and Eastern Europe.
Another 'problem' state was defeated Germany. The US wanted Germany to recover and become a useful obstacle to further Soviet expansion in Europe. The US and UK generally favoured imposing lighter war reparations on Germany. The Soviets wanted much higher reparations and that Germany be so industrially weakened that it could never mount an invasion of the USSR again. There was, too, disagreement as to who should be allowed to serve in public office in Germany. The Western leaders were not necessarily against those implicated in collusion with the ex-Nazi regime because their expertise was required. The USSR, in contrast, wanted such individuals banned from public careers.
The Allies did eventually agree to govern Germany with a joint administration, an approach also applied to the capital, Berlin, located in the USSR's zone of control in Germany. Austria, and its capital Vienna, was treated much the same way. Through 1946, Stalin essentially played a waiting game, believing that US troops in Europe would be withdrawn, as the US government had previously promised, and that the Western capitalist nations would eventually fall out with each other, as predicted by Marxist thought.
In January 1947, free elections were held in Poland, but these, Western governments believed, were blatantly manipulated by the Communists. The East-West relationship deteriorated further following the formal announcement, in March 1947, of the Truman Doctrine, and in June, Marshall Aid. The former was the idea that the US should promote freedom and democracy globally, not only for the good of other nations but also in order to create a more stable world free from tyranny. This strategy was also intended to achieve what became known as containment, that is, preventing any more states from becoming communist.
The Marshall Aid plan, named after the US general and Secretary of State George C. Marshall, began in 1947 and aimed to put the Truman Doctrine into practice. Economic aid was given to certain states to recover their economies after the devastation of the war. Again, the USA's intention was to ensure that prosperity guaranteed peace and defence against authoritarianism, and to promote future trade partners. At the same time, it was now clear that the US would maintain a permanent military presence in Europe, something Roosevelt had promised Stalin at Yalta would not happen. "The USA became in effect a European power" (Dear, 204). The US had already effectively occupied Japan. The Soviet reaction to these developments was further suspicion that the US intended to interfere in Soviet affairs in Central and Eastern Europe.
Some historians have pointed out that the Cold War was still not inevitable even in early 1947. The former allies of WWII had continued to cooperate in certain areas, notably in trials of war criminals such as the Nuremberg trials and the Far East war crime trials. However, certain political developments further soured East-West relations from the second half of 1947.
Stalin created Cominform in September 1947 to foster and control relations between the various Communist parties across Central and Eastern Europe. Western leaders believed the elections in Hungary in August 1947 had been rigged by the Communists. A Communist coup took place in Czechoslovakia in February 1948 and removed the democratically elected government. Then came the Berlin Blockade in June. The latter event had its origins in the reversal of the US promise that West Germany would remain a weakened and internationally governed state. After the events in Poland, Czechoslovakia, and Hungary, the US government believed that Germany must not be allowed to likewise fall under the sway of the USSR. In short, in the West, communism was now feared more than Germany. Stalin, on the other hand, believed that the beginning of the process of joining the international zones to create a unified West Germany (later called the Federal German Republic or FDR) was strong evidence that the West intended to attack the USSR at some point in the future. The Soviet response in the summer of 1948 was to deny the Western nations access to Berlin.
Stalin's intention in cutting off access to Berlin may have been to prevent West Germany from becoming part of the Western alliance of states. The US did not back down, though, and the Berlin Blockade was broken by 275,000 flights delivering 2.3 million tons of supplies into the city and taking out hundreds of thousands of tons of products made in the capital. Stalin had to back down, but East-West relations would never be the same again.
In 1949, then, the Grand Alliance was dead, and the world map of who was friendly with whom took on an entirely different appearance. A new frontier was drawn across Europe, what Churchill had described in a speech back in March 1946 as an "iron curtain," one which divided East and West and which stretched from Szczecin (Stettin) in northern Poland to Trieste on Italy's Adriatic coast.
The Western nations, led by the dominant partner, the USA, grouped together in 1949 and formed the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) for mutual military assistance. The US later pressed its allies to allow West Germany to join NATO. The Eastern nations, led by the USSR, formed the equivalent, the Warsaw Pact, in 1955. The division came to represent different ideas about democracy and the belief in the virtues of two economic systems: capitalism in the West and communism in the East. Another difference was the globalised relationships of the Western states and the virtual isolation of the Eastern bloc, although the USSR signed a treaty of friendship with Communist China in 1950.
The two blocs then entered a Cold War, that is, a period of rivalry based on weapons technology and the desire to alter the political futures of third-party nations. The two sides would not face each other in a direct 'hot' war, but rather, both sides sought to intervene politically, economically, and militarily in other states not yet fully aligned with either NATO or the Warsaw Pact. In Europe, in particular, both sides, East and West, became paranoid that the other side intended to cross the Iron Curtain with an invasion force. In reality, neither side had this intention. There was also paranoia about what each side's secret services, intelligence agencies, and spies were getting up to, in particular, the USA's CIA and the USSR's KGB. State-sponsored propaganda, the mass media, and films accentuated the atmosphere of fear and suspicion on both sides.
One cause for hope was that in 1945, both superpowers, the US and the USSR, had joined the United Nations, the international body of states that had replaced the prewar League of Nations. The UN began with 50 members and had a Security Council consisting of five permanent members: the US, USSR, UK, China, and France, each with a right of veto. Unfortunately for world peace, the UN became a forum for airing disputes and recriminations rather than one for solving problems and avoiding wars.
There was, besides a geopolitical rivalry between East and West, a competition in terms of weapons development, one which persistently raised the spectre of nuclear war. The USA had demonstrated its control of nuclear fission when it had dropped atomic bombs on Japan in 1945. The USSR, lagging behind, conducted its first successful nuclear test at Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan on 29 August 1949. Thus, there developed a nuclear arms race between East and West. Fortunately for everybody else, leaders on both sides realised that nuclear warfare could destroy the world, and so there was a certain restraint never to escalate to that level, even in such serious conflicts as the Korean War (1950 to 53) and the Vietnam War (1955 to 75). Yet another area of competition was the space race, that is, the desire to send satellites into space and gain the prestige of putting the first human on the Moon.
The Cold War transformed nations, dictated how people lived around the world, and coloured national and international politics for four decades. This strange war of ideas, threats, and brinkmanship finally came to an end in 1991 with the collapse of the USSR.